Valentine’s Day Murder Mystery Dinner Show at – Bay Shore, NY

Get your tickets to see Valentine’s Day Murder Mystery Dinner Show in Bay Shore, NY. Happening on Saturday, February 14, 2026 at . Doors open at 6:30 PM.

 
With a raging bride-zilla and an un-enthused groom on the scene, it may be happily never after in this nuptial nightmare!
Join us for an unforgettable evening at Fire Island Vines  
Theme: Wedding bells aren’t ringing for this not-so-happy couple when a member of the wedding party is murderered! And turns into a whodunit you won’t want to miss!
From mingling over a delicious buffet dinner to unraveling who are the suspects the The Murder Mystery Co.  will keep you laughing, guessing, and fully immersed in the fun.
Play detective as actors seated among you drop hints and involve everyone in solving the crime. Savor a delectable buffet dinner with three classic Italian entrées to choose from + Dessert Coffee ALL TAXES and Gratuities for Meal/Show included too 
Enjoy some drinks at the bar (don’t miss FIV’s famous homemade Sangria!)
The bride and groom aren’t picky, so you can wear just about whatever you’d like. 
All this for just $69—includes dinner, show, dessert, taxes, and gratuities.

Tickets-RSVP Link

Explore thousands of upcoming events, local tours, top restaurants, and the best places to stay in New York. You can also check out our dedicated city guide for Buffalo, and New York City.